trump's new press secretary has gotten caught with her pants down in her claim that she is an attorney. As she has not passed the bar, she is not an attorney, not even in China as she has also presumably claimed.
When I was a student at Howard University, I had a brilliant professor. She holds four impressive degrees including a JD. She has it all. So when I failed the bar the first time I was devastated and of course, I sought her out for comfort. That's the beauty of attending an HBCU, the ties are strong, always available, and never broken, they are for life! So, of course I reached out for encouragement.
I had failed only by a few points which made it just that much more devastating because I've got to do this shit all over again for maybe three points, I don't remember exactly, but it was miniscule.
So, when I called my brilliant professor, I couldn't believe my ears when she told me that she, too, had failed it the first time. After processing the shock of her admission, I felt less ashamed, and less critical of myself. I appreciated her being forthright and felt consoled knowing that I was in good company.
My professor went on to tell me the only person who never passes the bar is the person who stops taking it. She told me to take it again. I heeded her advice, took the bar exam again, and rode that horse right across the finish line to victory.
Failing the bar, however, was a humbling experience because it is so very public. Everyone who goes to law school is thought to be "smart", if for no other reason, because you got in. It doesn't help that law school culture feeds this stereotype.
Wallowing in embarrassment and self-pity, one can easily lose sight of the significant accomplishment of having survived law school and forget that you are smart and capable. Now you have to contend with everyone knowing you did not pass the bar, your law shool professors and colleagues, your family, friends, and all too happy enemies, and anyone else who wants or needs to know. Membership in the bar is public information and all too easy to access which makes it even more bizarre that this woman would not be forthcoming about not passing.
I never did pass the Pennsylvania Bar, however, which was the one I really wanted. Taking the bar is an exhausting experience. You have to really want to do it. I guess I didn't really want to do it...
Sometimes I admonish myself in self-talk that until I actively engage in the practice of law, I shouldn't allow me to call myself an attorney, figuratively because literally, of course, I'm an attorney and have the bar number to prove it. I beat myself up because I truly believe that not practicing is a disservice to my community, not to mention to myself because I'm still paying for this shit. But my community needs people like me to vigorously practice law and I know that.
This chick, however, makes me wear my Esquire badge even more boldly. Yes, I'm an attorney, practicing or not, I completed law school, passed that stupid ass bar exam, and I should not take those successes lightly.
It's amazing to me that so many people who have never taken a bar and who probably couldn't pass a bar if their life depended on it, sit in judgment of those who don't pass. That some of us respond, internalizing not passing as a failure that somehow negates or discounts that they've just completed three rigorous years of law school, which is no easy task, is sadly, also amazing. Block out the noise, which is probably mostly in your head, stand tall, and pat yourself on the back for a job well done, and take the exam again!
I was so impressed to read in Michelle Obama's book that she had not passed the bar the first time (Becoming, p. 154). I had to read it again. With that admission, I was even more sold that our forever First Lady, is a strong and confident Black Woman. Society has taught lawyers, no matter our success, to not talk about not passing the bar.
Passing the first time has ridiculously been equated to some status of honor. Law schools use first try passage results as a marketing tool. Lay people, who again, have never sat for a bar exam, will sometimes ask the question too, as if an attorney who had to take the bar more than once is somehow less competent or less qualified. Make that make sense...
The bar exam, as with most standardized tests, in no way predicts one's ability to apply the skill and perform the profession. The tests are often criticized for being culturally biased and some folks have been trained to test well. These exams were implemented as barriers to keep certain others out of said professions. The bar exam is intended to keep the practice of law white and male. Blacks nor women were welcome.
trump's press secretary got ensnared in the net cast by men like him, her brethren, if you will.
Until she passes the bar, according to the rules of her tribe, she cannot call herself an attorney. She simply holds the title of JD, which, by the way, is a very impressive title and degree that opens many doors affording one several distinctions of credibility. Deserved or not, one is stereotypically assumed to have a capacity for intellectual and mental stamina and the ability to think quickly, logically and critically in many subjects, even beyond the study of law. It's actually quite fascinating to witness.
Folks also get stuck on which law school did one attend, as if that matters. It's just another ridiculous qualifier that, at the end of the day, is less relevant than believed. You're a lawyer! Nobody much cares where you went to law school when you win their case.
If you didn't pass the bar, take it again and again until you conquer that last hurdle in the game of becoming a lawyer but don't hold yourself out as an attorney unless and until you pass the bar.
This woman does not appear to be the sharpest knife in the drawer and she took one of the hardest bars. The California bar exam ain't no joke, ask kim kardashian who might consider attending law school first since passage credentials are not for sale, no matter the bidder. I digress...
trump's new press secretary omitted a truth that is too easily discoverable, which makes her obviously incompetent, even at lying. So far, she's just another "dumb blonde" who will fit right in with the trump administration.
~ Miss Higgi Says

The press secretary was in full public display of what she projected the first day on the job. That is her incompetence along with her lack of integrity. But should we be surprised? I don’t believe we should, as the former press secretary and others have shown their total incompetence on full display not just this week but every single everyday.
ReplyDeleteA failure is a steppingstone to future success. The key is not to give up and you did not. Bravo!
ReplyDeleteThank you for this piece. As an attorney who retook the bar multiple times and says law school is hazing that you pay for, I agree with your perspective. Graduating law school, heck getting into law school is an accomplishment! Passing the bar is an accomplishment!
ReplyDeleteAmazing personal recap and reflection. The sad part is that for far too many people, they just don't get that experience and qualifications matter.
ReplyDeleteEveryone is not ready for the moment or opportunity without preparation. To simply throw people as he is doing and rejecting well-qualified people of Color because of the color of their skin is what makes his Administration the laughing stock of the world.
Great read!
ReplyDeleteGreat share..... The Bar is Bull...if you graduate law school, you should be a lawyer!
ReplyDeleteReminds me of my Cousin who worked really hard to prepare for the bar exam. We all knew and were all so proud of her because she had come so far and none of us had even seen law school in her future. But she literally pulled herself up by her bootstraps and we all thought the bar exam would be a piece of cake. That was maybe a dozen years ago and while I think she has probably retaken and passed the bar by now I can’t swear that she did. She was so devastated after failing the first time that I just never wanted to mention it to her. She is supposed to call me over the weekend and I think I might just summon up the courage to ask her. But maybe not.
ReplyDeleteI am not anonymous! I’m Jim Willis!!
DeleteWhat a powerful and much-needed message! Your intelligence, courage, and generosity in turning a personal experience into such a profound reflection are truly inspiring. You remind us that one setback does not define our abilities, and that true strength lies in recognizing our accomplishments without allowing the judgments of others to diminish who we are. So proud of you, my friend!
DeleteI too failed the Bar at 1st. I took NY & NJ, even though I never planned to practice, as I was already planning to work in the ADR field. I actually went to law school never planning to practice law.
ReplyDeleteThe 1st time, I failed NY by 3 points and NJ by just 1 point. My then boyfriend, now ex-husband, convinced me to try again.
Studying is exhausting, as in many professions. You eat, sleep, breathe the material. Flash cards at dinner, tapes on the train, every waking hour immersed in trying to memorize thousands of bits of information, knowing you’ll be asked about a few, and hoping you can remember the right ones.
I remember walking out of the Javits Center and calling my optometrist friend concerned because the Exit sign was blurry. She reassured me that it was just because I was doing intensive close work for 6 hours.
I took it again. Passed NJ and failed NY by 1 point. Begrudgingly took it a 3rd time and passed NY.
As planned, I never practiced law. The main benefit is that I get to say it’s my mediation skills that make me a good mediator, not being a lawyer.
Great post! Remember, orange said he would hire "only the best people". What a joke. The bar is now so low, we are tripping on it. He turned DEI into a slur, contributing to the loss of jobs for over 600,000 Black women since he took office. His administration tis filled with DEI (didn't earn it) hires who are unqualified for very serious jobs. Their incompetence has played a large role in causing significant harm on a global scale. Katie was not given the job because she was competent or admitted to a state bar. Her qualifications were blind loyalty to 🍊, willingness to lie shamelessly, and having blonde hair. By that metric, her brief tenure as WH press secretary was a success. What makes no sense are the lies regarding her status as a lawyer/attorney. Being a licensed attorney has never been a requirement for the job of press secretary. Why lie about something that can so easily be checked? This chaos is all so exhausting. Praying that this nightmare will be over soon. #voteblue
ReplyDeleteI am a good test-taker and passed the NY bar on the first try - but that is not a barometer of my intelligence or my skill at practicing law (from which I retired in favor of ADR). I remember media reports about John Kennedy Jr. repeatedly failing the NY bar and thinking how hard it would be to keep trying in the face of public humiliation. Of course, he did not invite the humiliation by representing himself to be an attorney when he was not one ....
ReplyDeleteOne of my friends failed the exam 8 times before she passed and she ended up being a law school professor. There may be some of you who know but I would not put her name without permission even though it is inspirational
ReplyDelete